Is it better to transfer or repay a mortgage?
If financing is repaid early, a prepayment penalty arises. As the financial institution has established a contractually fixed duration and a payment plan with interest, a penalty must be paid in the case of any early dissolution of that contract, depending on the market conditions since the mortgage was taken out. The amount of any penalty must always be calculated individually, as the remaining time to maturity, the interest rate and the loan amount all play an important role. Be sure to obtain all the important information before you decide on transferring or paying off a mortgage, and select the option that is the most beneficial to you financially.
If, after all calculations and considerations, you come to the conclusion that you would rather pay off the mortgage and pay the prepayment penalty, you should always check for any possible tax deduction. A Federal Court ruling from 2019 defined the following principles:
- In the case of early repayment and a new mortgage with the same financial institution, the prepayment penalty can be deducted from income as debt interest
- In the case of early repayment and a new mortgage with a different financial institution, it is considered compensation and cannot be deducted
- In the case of early repayment because of the sale of the property, the penalty payment is considered an investment cost in the real estate gains tax